Skip to content

Georgie Porgie puddin’ and pie, kissed the girls & made them cry…Will George Anthony hand deliver Casey to the prosecution on a silver platter?

March 12, 2010

George's alleged mistress sitting behind Anthonys' at Caylee memorial

WFTV is reporting that detectives have questioned a woman who claims to have had an affair with George Anthony.  The woman looks strikingly like the Zenaida Gonzalez that George described to detectives as “Zanny the Nanny”, the supposed kidnapper of Caylee Anthony.  The woman’s sister, Sky Benhaida, (pronounced Ben-hide-a. Yep, rhymes with Zenaida) says that she thinks George used her sister as a model for what Zenaida G. looks like–right down to “nice teeth and a tattoo down her left arm.”

Benhaida says that her sister told investigators that she had a year long affair with George that began shortly after Casey was arrested in connection with Caylee’s death.  She says her sister took a lie detector test and was questioned for hours by detectives.  She claims her sister was in love with George and gave him around $5000 over the course of their affair.  The investigators told her that George had taken money from other women as well.

Skye Benhaida (Ben-hide-a) twin sister of alleged mistress

The sister claims to have phone photos with George in “intimate” situations and gave them to the detectives along with numerous text messages from George’s 3 cell phones.

Benhaida said that George told her sister that Caylee’s death was an accident but her sister never questioned him further about it.

She told him that, ‘I would never ask you that. ”  He allegedly responded that it was an accident that snowballed out of control.

Legal analyst Bill Sheaffer says this could be bad news for Casey Anthony if it’s true.

“This would apparently foreclose any defense that someone outside of the Anthony family is responsible for that child’s death,” said Sheaffer.

George Anthony’s attorney says he has not received any information from investigators concerning this information, but he didn’t deny the affair took place.  He didn’t answer any direct questions.

Casey Anthony’s defense spokesperson responded to questions with “no comment.”

read it below:

watch the video at  this link to see alleged mistress sitting behind and on the left of the Anthonys’ at Caylee memorial.   Kathi Belich looks almost ecstatic as she reports this story 🙂

Holy Crap-oly!  Could this have anything to do with the state asking Judge Strickland to withhold new discovery from the defense?  If it does, it’s certainly a twist that no one could have imagined!  George may take Casey down in spite of himself. If it weren’t all so utterly pathetic and disgusting it would almost be funny.

57 Comments leave one →
  1. Molly permalink
    March 13, 2010 2:47 am

    mystery – here is video of skye & her sister at the memorial one row back from the Ants!
    oh georgie, georgie, georgie

  2. Sanny permalink
    March 13, 2010 2:54 am

    Why is this just coming out now?
    Does this have anything at all to do with the State’s ‘secret’ evidence?

    Benhaida pronounced as in Zenaida….what a coincidence.
    Right down to the tattoo on left arm that Zanny the Nanny is supposed to have.
    Even if this latest BOMBSHELL is questionable, Cindy must be hammering at George for some answers and she won’t stand for any Miss-Truths either.
    However you look at this, George has alot of answering to do.

    Oh….mg…..let me be a fly on the Anthonys’ and the D-Teams wall please.

    What else will come out between now and the trial?

  3. mikka permalink
    March 13, 2010 7:25 am

    molly ,thanks ,
    itsamystery,when cindy are not so stupid,i can feel sorry for her,daughter is a murderer,grandchild lost,husband cheater,and the another site,i dont blame geo either,may he just want on this time a shoulder to cry on it!NOT! 😆

  4. mikka permalink
    March 13, 2010 8:18 am

    will geo now take the 5th at trial??? 🙄

  5. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 13, 2010 8:51 am


    thanks for pointing that out. I added photos and an update to the post. The problem with George making up the name is that, unless their affair went on a lot longer than is being reported, Casey mentioned the name way before this woman came into the picture—didn’t she?

  6. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 13, 2010 8:53 am

    Sanny–I guess it’s just been uncovered. Makes me think it does have something to do with the new discovery the state was talking about.

    If it’s true then it could mean that George helped Casey cover up what happened to Caylee.

    An accident gone awry? The duct tape begs to differ.

  7. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 13, 2010 8:55 am

    mikka–Noooooo, I don’t feel sorry for Cindy. I did at one time, but not now. I wouldn’t be surprised if she wasn’t surprised by this latest news.

    I don’t know if he’ll be able to take the 5th?

  8. mikka permalink
    March 13, 2010 9:46 am

    itsamystery,i mean when cindy is a normal good woman(but we know she is not normal and good) than i feel sorry! 🙂

  9. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 13, 2010 10:09 am

    i agree!

  10. LVSusie permalink
    March 13, 2010 10:19 am

    I have a question for you Mystery or anyone that can answer, who said Zenida had a tattoo on her arm? I dont see in any of Casey, Cindy and Georges discription on Zanny the Nanny where a tattoo was mentioned on her arm, just 5′ 7″ brown curly hair worn straight sometimes about 140 pds was from New York, black/hispanic decent. did I miss something??

  11. T-L-I-O-T-G permalink
    March 13, 2010 10:58 am

    Wow G-boy ya really iced the cake with this one ,you belong in jail too along with Crazsey and the Whackjob.
    I got dollars to donuts that they all turn on each other now,they gotta look after there own Lie’n asses,say Heehaw folks,this just keeps gett’n better.
    Hose B must be in WTF mode!
    Like this bunch have not humiliated them selves enuff in public!
    I say they should both go for a ride in the SSCaylee in a storm,lost at sea.Who’s going to care!

  12. Spacely permalink
    March 13, 2010 12:01 pm

    Every single time something crazy happens in this case, I tell myself it just can’t get any more bizarre, but this family proves me wrong every time.

    These events certainly throw a new light on George’s recent diatribe about microscopes. He must have known this was coming.

    One article I read the sister said he had done this to multiple women. Makes you wonder if this will be like the Tiger Woods story and mistresses will keep popping up saying they thought they were the only one?

    And what kind of accident “snowballs out of control” and ends up with your granddaughter in a trash bag near your house? That is not an accident. That is the result of self-love over all else as the only way that could happen is during the cover-up of an accident – something you do to protect yourself or perhaps your daughter instead of taking responsibility for the death of your loved ones and calling in the authorities.

    I just can’t believe he pulled this off for this long without the media already blowing the story wide open.

    I am trying my best to remember, but I don’t believe that KC actually gave a physical description of Zanny beyond Hispanic with hair and kids and a mom – I even think the sister came from the conversation at the house for which we only have other family and Padilla reports. So, if the affair started after KC was arrested, it was like half a month before George made his statement about her description – like the very end of July – because they quit cooperating with police like day 2.

  13. Molly permalink
    March 13, 2010 12:11 pm

    Yes, neverending drama in this case. always expect the unexpected.
    I don’t rememer George describing a tattoo either. He never saw the nanny! don’t know if that was part of casey’s descriptio either.

    could this be the “don’t worry i didn’t say anything” comment made in the jail video?

  14. glen permalink
    March 13, 2010 12:18 pm

    Casey had to know about the affair before going to jail, she told her friend Amy her parents were getting divorced because her dad had an affair… that is why she was to get the house. Goeorge, shame on you bagging another woman while you were supose be looking for Caylee,she was that important to you or was it because you knew she was already dead…You and your family should have to repay all monies spent looking for her..I am so glad the state is questioning the idegent app…

  15. glen permalink
    March 13, 2010 12:24 pm

    I think casey gave a description saying she had a tatoo, one thing for sure she (this Woman) is now in the middle of things like it or not

  16. glen permalink
    March 13, 2010 12:26 pm

    i also believe this is what the state asked to keep from the public,which Judge
    s has that information sealed for now

  17. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 13, 2010 2:32 pm


    I don’t recall him saying she had a tattoo on her arm. Here’s some interesting tidbits from George’s ZG deposition:

    page 9:
    Q: Ok. And what was the circumstances the very 1st time you heard it? (the name ZG)
    A: When my granddaughter came missing.
    Q: And was it–how did you hear the name? Zanny? Is that the way you heard it?
    A: You just asked me about Zenaida Gonzalez. I didn’t hear that name, sir, until July of 2008.
    Q: Ok when was the 1st time you ever heard the name Zenny–Zanny? Would that be the same time?
    A: No sir. I heard that about a year prior to that.
    page 13:
    Q: How did she describe–during that year before the disappearance, did she ever describe Zanny to you? (“she” being Casey)
    A: I never heard a description of Zanny til all this stuff happened in July of 2008
    page 22:
    A: I’m going to cut to your chase right now so you can get away with all these questions. Number one is the Zanny that my daughter described to me is 24 to 25 years old, about 5’7″, 125, 130 lbs. She had straight white teeth, long brown hair. On a scale of one to ten, she’s a 10 supposedly.

    Interesting. No tattoo mentioned at that particular time. Did Casey ever mention the full actual full name” Zenaida Gonzalez” BEFORE July of 2008? Or was it always just “Zanny”?

  18. EDRN permalink
    March 13, 2010 2:42 pm

    Can anyone site a place where the tattoo is mentioned in anyones depo/interview?

  19. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 13, 2010 3:07 pm


    Yes, I think George has at the very least humiliated himself and his family and might have secured himself new living quarters if any of this really rings true!!

  20. March 13, 2010 3:17 pm

    Hi Mystery and everyone here, I remember Casey said there were no tatoos on Zanny but then she would not want to say the Nanny had tatoos as Casey’s Zanny is fictional and she was using the sawgrass Zenaida and she could see she has tattoos so better at least leave something as noticeable as the Zenaida’s tatoo’s out of the picture. That way she can claim is was not that Zenaida she was trying to set up. I agree with the other’s why wait this long? Also, why is the sister telling this story instead of the sister that had the actual supposed affair with George? I cannot help it but to me this makes me think Baez is back to his shananigans and he is behind this coming forward now just as he was behind the jill kerley,Crystal Sparks, and all that mess to vilify kronk and to me it is just as crazy as the kronk mess. George could have had this affair who knows yet but in my opinion it has nothing to do with who killed Caylee. I believe Baez MO is the crazier, bizarre and twisted i can get this case the more doubt i can bestow on my client.

  21. March 13, 2010 3:19 pm

    oh and Mystery i love your title,. lmho.

  22. mikka permalink
    March 13, 2010 4:40 pm

    looks like cma never say the full name ,only zanny!but no matter what this zanny-nanny dont excist! 😉

  23. March 13, 2010 8:00 pm

    This whole situation just keeps getting more and more heartbreaking. What a mess.

  24. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 13, 2010 8:01 pm


    Not that I can find, and I’ve been looking. I also don’t think that Casey referred to ZG by name to anyone until July 15th. At least not that I can find YET.

  25. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 13, 2010 8:04 pm

    knight owl

    Thanks. 😆

    Could be–time will tell. I assume we will eventually know what the new discovery was. I agree it is odd they waited this long to come forward.

  26. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 13, 2010 8:06 pm


    I sure haven’t found where she called her Zenaida Gonzalez according to any of her friends. I obviously haven’t revisited every deposition, so I could be wrong.

  27. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 13, 2010 8:07 pm

    Hi Monica–

    Yes, it is a mess and getting messier.

  28. Hadley permalink
    March 14, 2010 5:19 am

    Didn’t she, at one time, call her Zenaida “Fernandez” Gonzalez? This whole case is getting more WEIRD and more CONFUSING byy the day! Wonder why this new affair is just now coming out? The timing seems rather strange…with the foreclosure, and Casey being broke etc…

    I think when that “other show” finally drops, we are going to see a real BOMBSHELL!

    Rest Peacefully Baby Caylee, you are loved and missed by so many.

  29. Hadley permalink
    March 14, 2010 5:23 am

    When that other shoe drops we are going to see a “real” bombshell.

  30. Ideas permalink
    March 14, 2010 6:51 am

    How did George think he could set Skye up as the nanny? Did he want her to take the fall, or was he just using her as a description to make the nanny sound like a real person? If LE followed up with her as the nanny, wouldn’t they find out about George’s affair with her? That doesn’t make sense to me, although maybe to George. But what does this say about his character? It’s one thing to have an affair, which is bad enough, but to set someone else up as a fall guy because they are hispanic by way of a “love” relationship is worse.

  31. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 14, 2010 6:52 am


    Yes, she did, but when was the first time anyone in her circle heard that actual name? Was it really July 15th the first time she used it? Was she referred to as the Nanny or Zanny before that? If that’s the case it would make it more believable that George might have made up her name (searched online etc) as this woman is claiming. If not, I have trouble buying it and agree this is weird timing and something is up.

  32. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 14, 2010 6:59 am


    I doubt he was using her as a fall guy–more like a description . JMO. I mean, if he tried that I would guess she’d sing like a canary. (which may be what happened) lol.

    I wonder if LE knew about this woman til recently and this is the “new discovery”. Or, for all we know they’ve known about it for a long time if they were watching George. OR, it may turn out to not be true, and this is another smokescreen to detract from some other “bombshell”. Who knows with these people! 🙄

  33. March 14, 2010 8:27 am

    Hi all!
    Spacely “Every single time something crazy happens in this case, I tell myself it just can’t get any more bizarre, but this family proves me wrong every time.”

    You nailed it! That is EXACTLY how I explained it to me girl.

    Maybe it’s due to a strict (but very loving) Scot upbringing but I have NEVER “borrowed” (yeah, right. Borrowing implies an intention of repayment) money off of a girlfriend. I was ENGAGED and hated to let her put gas in me car. Not that Georgette ever let pride get in the way.

    Smile, all! We are witnessing a classic example of what goes around comes around.
    Take care and God bless!

  34. david permalink
    March 14, 2010 11:17 am

    Ya gotta know that the cops are all over this for a looong time! Ferreting out what the other G said to the other gals, piecing it all together…now we know why they all wouldnt take a lie detector test early on…why Padilla claims G lied about seeing them on the 16th…why G wasnt searching for Caylee…the fake suicide…the coded chats in the jail…the bogus Zanny ID…all of it…no wonder Casey is so warped…just look at her parents…the frantic cell calls the day Caylee died…then Dad concocts the story cuz their warped sense of values suggest they can hide it all if no one talks…the cop in him covers for daughter…I dont think Cindy was in on it..her 911 call was real…George knew when he smelled the trunk…the pool ladder being moved…the cav dog hits in the yard…yup….one big cover up for out of control…but hey will nail Casey…until dad doesnt let her take the needle…he has no guts and is a manipulative whimpering weak shell shell…he needs to come clean..…more arrest must be coming…perhaps they’ll all be in jail in a few years…then there will be justice for Caylee…..better take one last cruise with some other gals money…may be the last….its all unraveling…..

  35. lona1 permalink
    March 14, 2010 12:00 pm

    Me thinks the Anthonys will be in court hand in hand on Thursday and and enjoy the limelight.

  36. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 14, 2010 3:09 pm


    Yeah, IMO, it’s not right to accept a loan from a girlfriend (or boyfriend for that matter)–no matter what the circumstances and even in a legitimate relationship. I have no respect for Cindy or George but he’s taken it all to a new low. I didn’t think that was possible.

    As for the woman? Sorry. She got what she deserved. He’s a married man. She knew he was married and had the extreme disrespect to sit behind George’s wife and son at his granddaughter’s memorial. No matter what I think of Cindy, she didn’t deserve that and neither did Lee. In that one act she showed us what kind of person she is–so tough luck, girlie. Is she trying to make up for her affair with George by coming forward all these months later?

    George has also revealed what kind of man he is, not only by his infidelity, but by allowing her to be at the memorial.

    Gigolo George…….Gag me. 😡

  37. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 14, 2010 3:15 pm


    I think it’s possible that he did concoct this whole story BUT, Casey doesn’t strike me as the type that would go down alone. If it really were an accident, I think Casey would have eventually come clean when she realized she could get the needle and say that her Dad concocted the whole story –she would say the truth is Caylee drowned accidentally in the pool or whatever. Plus it doesn’t explain the duct tape, and I cannot fathom a granfather tossing his beloved granddaughter’s body into the woods to rot.

    None of it makes any sense, but I still think it’s possible……..Anything’s possible with this bunch of mutants.

  38. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 14, 2010 3:17 pm


    preening for the cameras!!

  39. Hadley permalink
    March 14, 2010 4:37 pm


    I imagine Skye woman, and her sister are ready to talk to the National Enquirer…just a strong feeling I have.

    Maybe when all of the “facts” come out, the Defence will ask for a plea deal. Of course, one has to be offered.

    All the disrespect, and money making, scams, lies, adultry is horrid to the memory of precious little Caylee. The Anthonys can’t get much lower; but somehow, I know they will! Money seems to be all they really love and care about. I’ve got news for them, it will NEVER bring them Peace or Happiness.

    The “woman” said that Geo. even phoned her from the so-called “suicide motel”….the ba$tard had no intention of killing himself! He just wanted to get sloshed, and have time away from Cindy. Karma is ready to KICK, and KICK HARD!

  40. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 14, 2010 6:07 pm

    Hadley—I wouldn’t be surprised either–unless the woman is going to be a witness for the prosecution. I suppose her sister could still make some deals…..

    I think it’s way past plea dealing. The prosecution has a strong case now and Casey’s window of opportunity is long gone.

    I keep thinking that the Anthonys can’t sink much lower and then they do so I’m sure there’s more to come. I hadn’t heard that George called her from the motel where he was threatening suicide. Disgusting man. I’m sorry but I don’t think she’s any better than he is if it’s true.

  41. lona1 permalink
    March 14, 2010 9:18 pm

    Richard hornsby speaks!
    This will blow your mind….listen to ALL OF IT!

  42. Hadley permalink
    March 14, 2010 9:47 pm

    It’s true. She was answering questions on a blog site and said that.

    I have a feeling that Cindy is next to have a Bomb dropped on her!

    I just wish this trial was OVER, and that Justice for precious Caylee would be served!

    Oh, it appears that “Skye” has been blog hopping…does she need attention that bad? I truly do not understand that! “Something is not right…it’s almost like it was planned.” People keep asking about the 10 Casey mentioned…she got that from watching One Tree Hill…the beautiful girl on the show was a 10, and a baby was kidnapped.(for what it’s worth..haha)

  43. Jill from Western Australia permalink
    March 15, 2010 3:56 am

    Iona1 😆 I just posted the link at Niecey’s before I came here and saw you did the same.

    I listened for the full hour and recommend that everyone else does.


  44. lona1 permalink
    March 15, 2010 9:00 am

    Affair! Affair! Affair!
    Who cares what they do with their ‘stuff’.

  45. lona1 permalink
    March 15, 2010 9:01 am

    Please sing along,

    diversion, diversion, scamversion, scamversion!

  46. lona1 permalink
    March 15, 2010 9:02 am

    where’s my comment?
    I’ll type it again.

    Please sing along,

    diversion, diversion, scamversion, scamversion lol

  47. lona1 permalink
    March 15, 2010 9:04 am

    Yep, Baez is going to be busy scapeing cow manure off his shoes because the chit is about to hit the fan!

  48. lona1 permalink
    March 15, 2010 9:05 am


  49. T-L-I-O-T-G permalink
    March 15, 2010 10:26 am

    That was a good point how Katie B who has Dogged the Hosey one,has been muzzled!!
    He’s history ,not a one of them can or will tell the truth,he will be up for disbarment!
    Give her a PD and lets start grounds for an appeal ,Crazsey cripy like a piece of beacon,is what i would like to see.

  50. lona1 permalink
    March 15, 2010 11:10 am

    Yes, ABC will make Baez the fall guy.

  51. Rosemary permalink
    March 15, 2010 12:11 pm

    George is a waste in any sense of the word. He was all willing to talk about the smell in the car, but for some reason- backtracted on that.
    His affair ( if he had one) was probably to get money, sympathy and any other thing he could use women for- including the description on ZG.
    casey said ZG and her sister ( along with sis’s kids) were at the park and took Caylee. I think they met this woman at the search site, and because she fit the description on ZG- were going to use her to pin as the kidnapper- but then she and George got close and he didn’t want anyone to know about it- so- they start blaming others, Jesse grund, Roy Kronk- any one but Casey.

  52. Rosemary permalink
    March 15, 2010 12:13 pm

    I hope there is a way for this poor lady to contact me. I feel bad for her and want to offer support. This family is nuts- it seems anyone who had any contact with them, end up with their lives disrupted. sickoos!

  53. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 15, 2010 12:23 pm

    lona thanks for the link. I posted on it. Very interesting stuff.

  54. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 15, 2010 12:30 pm


    I agree that there are some real problems with Skye’s story, and it appears, like Kiomarie Cruz, and many others, she has gotten caught up in the attention.

    Until we know more we can only speculate as to whether or not this story is bs or the BS (bullsh*t or the BIG STORY) By the big story I mean if it’s revealed that George helped Casey concoct a story to cover up what she did. The affair itself matters not one whit.

  55. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 15, 2010 12:31 pm

    lona–sorry, your comment got caught in spam for some reason.

  56. itsamysterytome permalink*
    March 15, 2010 12:33 pm


    Good points. I’m starting to think not only the whole family is nuts–but everyone around them.

  57. E Daisy permalink
    March 15, 2010 9:29 pm

    I’m sure George made the comment in question long before the body was found. It’s got to be one of those stupid things said off-the-cuff that is his actual opinion. In public he cannot contradict Cindy. First of all, regardless of his current activities, he’s married. You support your spouse even if you think they’re full of it. (You can see this in one of the Larry King interviews where George starts to go off-script and Cindy shoots him a look.) George may very well be Casey’s undoing, but that’s to be expected. He said as much when he testified before the grand jury.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: